PEP Library
Commentaries

January 2023 – Commentary from Dan Pickering

Full Post
Now that’s how you start a year. January saw the stock market explode out of the gates with the S&P500 rallying +6.3% and the Nasdaq Composite jumping +10.7%...

Now that’s how you start a year.  January saw the stock market explode out of the gates with the S&P500 rallying +6.3% and the Nasdaq Composite jumping +10.7%.  At +3.0%, Diversified Energy (S&P 1500 Energy, S15ENRS) lagged the broad indices, with subsector performance as follows – Oilfield Services +8.6% (OIH), Midstream +6.5% (AMZ), and Upstream/E&P +3.7% (XOP). Clean energy added +4.5% (ICLN).  Crude oil fell -1.7% (~$78.90) while natural gas continued its implosion by falling -40% (~$2.70/mcf).(1)

Items of note during January and early February:

  • Optimism was rampant in January.  Remembering that bad news is good news for those expecting interest rates to moderate, January’s economic data was just bad enough to spark a meaningful rally.  Bullish technical levels were breached to the upside and FOMO kicked in.  This is either the proverbial Wall of Worry being climbed or a sweet-smelling honey pot squeezing out the bears before a pullback.  With call option volume hitting the highest level in history on February 2nd and meme stocks ramping, we’re inclined to tread carefully.
  • Natural gas gapped down again as warm weather across the globe took down European prices (one year forward TTF dropped from ~89€/MWh to ~63€/MWh) and the US as well.  It appears that US market participants are going to sell/short natural gas until the industry starts to moderate supply via lower drilling and completion activity.  We’ve heard anecdotes of an impending rigcount slowdown among a few gassy private operators, but it does not appear that gassy public E&Ps have blinked yet.  We expect they will with any longevity of Henry Hub prices around $2.50/mcf (currently ~$2.40/mcf).
  • Looking ahead in the oil macro, sanctions on Russian products will begin in early February.  Oil sanctions have been a nothing-burger (so far), so perhaps the same will be true of products.  The market feels a bit lulled to sleep on Russia – which is always when hell breaks loose.  We continue to “take the over” on long-dated oil futures – 2025 closed January at ~$69.10 and feels too cheap in a world that has underinvested in supply.
  • At the early February meeting, OPEC rolled its current production levels.  Expected and overall supportive, a trend we believe will continue for the foreseeable future.
  • Cracks are beginning to appear in the US oilfield service story.  We’ve heard a number of oily players complain of deteriorating well economics due to increased well costs and the pullback of oil prices into the $70’s.  With gas economics adding insult to injury, the anecdotes are emerging of US rig rates pulling back from recent highs, tubulars getting easier to find and gaps developing in frac schedules.  Absolute levels of profitability are still solid for oilfield service players, but the momentum seems to be shifting back to E&P customers.
  • In conjunction with its Q4 earnings results, European major BP announced it would invest $8B more in hydrocarbon projects between now and 2030.  This will result in a production drop of -25% vs. 2019 levels, a bump up from the prior guidance of -40%.  Carbon emissions will also be reduced less than previously targeted.  BP cloaked this move in terms of adapting to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and the subsequent shifting energy priorities of global governments.  We agree Russia/Ukraine has changed the calculus (recall our 10-months-in-a-row Trustworthy Barrels mantra from 2022).  However, we see BP’s move as crying uncle – the stock has been a dramatic underperformer since its February 2020 pivot toward renewables.  While the environmental community will probably tear the company to shreds for backpedaling, investors clearly liked the move.  BP’s stock jumped +8.3% (vs. XLE +3.2%) on the date of BP’s announcement.
  • The cash generating power of the energy sector has been reinforced during Q4 earnings, most notably with Chevron’s $75B share repurchase authorization.  Capital discipline remains excellent across the sector.  On a relative basis, Conoco’s uptick in capex guidance was punished by investors.  This certainly seems to indicate return-of-capital remains a higher priority to institutional players than hydrocarbon production growth.
  • Energy stocks held up well in January considering commodities were uninspiring and money was chasing/rotating toward tech.  The crowd that ramps Nvidia isn’t (yet) the same crowd that generally owns energy.  It isn’t fair to call energy slow-and-steady considering all the macro/micro dynamics and volatility, but we’re happy to plod ahead with status quo behavior in the energy sector – it’ll be a winner over the next few years.

Please remember the PEP organization is standing by to help – whether it be investment exposure, capital needs, energy market intelligence or help with a specific problem. As always, we appreciate your interest and welcome your questions.

  1. Source: Bloomberg

January 2023 – Commentary from Dan Pickering

Timeframe

Add to calendar

Location

No items found.

Connect

No items found.

Sponsored

PEP Library

Explore Our Latest Insights

Visit page
Visit Library post
Transaction Creates Clean Energy Platform Spanning Residential, Commercial, and Utility Markets
Visit page
Visit Library post
Patience remains the mantra
Visit page
Visit Library post
Can’t keep a bull market down!
Visit page
Visit Library post
CNBC’s “Power Lunch” team is joined by with Dan Pickering, founder and CIO of Pickering Energy Partners, to discuss the threat of tariffs on oil and energy, the potential impact on costs and more.
Visit page
Visit Library post
After two years of rapid dealmaking, U.S. oil M&A has hit pause amid volatile prices and geopolitical shocks; experts predict months before major deals revive.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Oil and Gas Investor's 2025 class of honorees are changing the future of their company and the energy industry.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Graham Conway, PhD and Director at Pickering Energy Partners, presented our June Market Analysis and Transportation in Review, highlighting a critical policy move. The EPA’s Set 2 proposal, released June 13, marks a meaningful pivot in biofuels strategy.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Shell refutes a Wall Street Journal report of early merger talks with BP, but speculation underscores BP’s vulnerability and the industry-shaking scale of any tie-up.
Visit page
Visit Library post
AI arms race fuels gas-heavy continuation vehicle wave
Visit page
Visit Library post
Dan Pickering, Founder and CIO of Pickering Energy Partners, sees supply and demand concerns returning to the forefront of the oil market with the removal of geopolitical risk from the Israel-Iran ceasefire.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Crude oil prices, maybe surprisingly, dipped modestly on Monday after spiking at the end of last week, even as Iran and Israel continue firing
Visit page
Visit Library post
Energy Aspects’ Richard Bronze and Pickering Energy Partners’ Dan Pickering, join ‘The Exchange’ to discuss the Israel-Iran conflict and how it may impact the oil sector.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Dan Pickering, Founder & CIO from Pickering Energy Partners, joins CNBC’s Dan Murphy to talk oil prices, and he says OPEC will win the market share war.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Rebound Month. The market turned up hard and energy followed
Visit page
Visit Library post
What if our path to energy decarbonization and global energy dominance didn’t rely on more rules, more penalties, and more government overreach, but instead on competition, transparency, and financial reward?
Ready to get started?
Contact our specialized teams at PEP for more information.