Oil Giants’ Soaring Profits Clash With Waning Momentum in Stocks

Full Post
Oil and gas companies are expected to report enormous profit growth as the war in Iran drives energy prices higher, but their stocks continue to underperform because investors question whether those gains will last. Political sensitivity and uncertainty around oil prices may also make companies reluctant to immediately increase dividends or stock buybacks.

US oil and gas companies are set for a blockbuster earnings season, helped by energy prices that have been soaring as the war in Iran persists. Yet, that may still fail to pull the stocks out of their rut.

Energy companies are estimated to report a 129% jump in second-quarter earnings from a year ago, according to data compiled by Bloomberg Intelligence. That would be the biggest such expansion among all sectors in the S&P 500 Index.

Meanwhile, energy stocks have risen about 5.4% since the beginning of the Iran conflict, lagging the US equity benchmark’s 6.4% jump over the same period while Brent crude futures advanced 24%.

Since it’s difficult to ascertain how long a geopolitically driven oil price escalation will last, “the market has tended to discount the sustainability of high prices and you see that in the way it is treating the oil and gas companies,” Dan Pickering, chief investment officer at Pickering Energy Partners, said in an interview.

The uncertainty surrounding the war in the Middle East has whipsawed energy stocks since late February, depending on whether there’s an escalation in the conflict that pushes oil prices higher or a ceasefire, as investors try to make sense of the daily headlines. XLE, an exchange-traded fund that tracks the sector, shed $2.5 billion in the second quarter and has posted outflows for the month through July 24.

Chevron Corp. and ExxonMobil Holdings Corp. will kick off earnings for the integrated oil companies on Friday. Chevron is expected to see a 219% year-over-year growth in profit in the second quarter, and ExxonMobil is estimated to report a 116% gain. Shares of Chevron and Exxon are up about 3% since the war began in late February.

Next week, results are due from ConocoPhillips, EOG Resources Inc., Occidental Petroleum Corp. and Diamondback Energy Inc., among other large US energy stocks.

So far, even some of the companies that have posted second-quarter earnings that exceeded estimates, like SLB Ltd. and peer Baker Hughes Co., are still down since the Iran war started in late February. Refiner HF Sinclair Corp., meanwhile, has bucked that trend, with earnings that surpassed expectations and an 80% jump in share prices over that period.

Profit and Cash Gains

Investors will be focused on how major energy firms like Chevron and ExxonMobil plan to spend their money, given that their free cash flow estimates for the second quarter show at least triple-digit growth.

“We’d love to see business continue as usual and if they get a little bit of a windfall, can they buy back stock if it’s a reasonable price, can they increase their dividend?” Brian Laks, chief investment officer at Old West Investment Management, said in an interview.

But increased shareholder returns may not materialize just yet, according to TD Cowen analyst Jason Gabelman.

“Given the potential transient nature of the commodity strength, I think they may be a bit hesitant to raise the buyback just yet,” Gabelman said in an interview. “There’s also of course political sensitivities to that. You don’t want to make it seem like higher oil prices, which tend to be politicized, are resulting in windfall earnings.”

Canadian major energy producers are also expected to see profit growth when they report earnings in August. Suncor Energy Inc. is expected to see a 323% growth in earnings, while Canadian Natural Resources Ltd. is expected to see a 181% gain. The firms benefited from increased demand for oil outside of the Middle East, with Suncor rising 20% since late February while Canadian Natural Resources is up 9%.

For now, estimates show that major US oil companies are expected to continue to see earnings growth in the third quarter. Some longer-term investors in the energy sector see a fundamental case for the stocks regardless of how the Middle East conflict impacts companies in the sector.

“We don’t view it as ‘you can only like these things because there’s a war and we get this temporary boost,’” Old West’s Laks said. “We liked them when oil was at $60 or $70, and if you get these temporary disruptions and it’s at $90, well that’s just a bonus.”

Read now
Oil Giants’ Soaring Profits Clash With Waning Momentum in Stocks

Timeframe

Add to calendar

Location

No items found.

Connect

No items found.

Sponsored

PEP Library

Explore Our Latest Insights

Visit page
Visit Library post
Oil and gas companies are expected to report enormous profit growth as the war in Iran drives energy prices higher, but their stocks continue to underperform because investors question whether those gains will last. Political sensitivity and uncertainty around oil prices may also make companies reluctant to immediately increase dividends or stock buybacks.
Visit page
Visit Library post
President Trump initially celebrated rising oil prices because they boosted U.S. energy profits. However, after the Iran war pushed crude prices from roughly $66 to an average of $95 per barrel between March and June, oil companies and their allies are now poised to receive major financial gains. The situation has become politically inconvenient for Trump, who is no longer pleased with the consequences of the price surge.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Iran’s renewed threat to the Strait of Hormuz leaves Trump facing a stark choice as oil reserves shrink, fuel prices rise, and the conflict escalates.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Oil prices climb as cracks in the U.S.-Iran cease-fire, renewed Hormuz tensions, and potential strikes revive volatility in global energy markets.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Voting machine vs. weighing machine. The voting machine is winning.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Visit page
Visit Library post
Visit page
Visit Library post
The global oil market has avoided the catastrophic supply crunch many feared when the Iran war broke out, but it’s far from balanced.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Fitch Ratings upgraded its oil and gas sector outlook to “improving” from “neutral,” and Moody’s maintained its positive outlook.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Oil markets remain highly volatile as the Iran War enters its fourth month. Energy expert Dan Pickering discusses the structural shifts triggered by the Strait of Hormuz closure and how investors can navigate a market increasingly disconnected from facts on the front lines.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Same story, different day
Visit page
Visit Library post
Oil and gas production won’t rebound quickly even if the Iran war ends soon. Why Devon Energy, Baker Hughes, and other stocks can weather the storm.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Other than that Mrs. Lincoln, how was the play?
Visit page
Visit Library post
The U.S. and Iran are each trying to trigger economic damage to make the other side relent. The standoff risks worsening the damage across the global economy.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Europe faces widening fuel shortages as Middle East conflict strains global energy supplies, with jet fuel shortfalls expected to hit California and the West Coast.
Ready to get started?
Contact our specialized teams at PEP for more information.