PEP Library
Commentaries

April 2025 - Commentary from Dan Pickering

Full Post
A rough month. Energy was the worst subsector in an incredibly choppy market.

A rough month.  Energy was the worst subsector in an incredibly choppy market during April on a combination of “Liberation Day” tariff/economy concerns and the prospect of rising OPEC+ volumes.  The S&P500 fell -0.7%, the Nasdaq gained +0.9%, while Diversified Energy dropped -13.8% (S&P 1500 Energy, S15ENRS) as YTD gains were erased.  April’s energy subsector performance was as follows: Midstream -8.8% (AMZ), Upstream -15.9% (XOP), Oilfield Services -20.2% (OIH) and Clean Energy as the standout at +3.1% (ICLN).  Front month WTI oil fell notably, dropping -19% (from ~$71.50/bbl to ~$58.20/bbl) and Henry Hub reversed course, also falling -19% to close at ~$3.35/mmbtu.(1)  


ENERGY MACRO

  • During April, crude fell precipitously in reaction to the double whammy of tariffs and accelerated OPEC+ supply increases.  From ~$71.50/bbl at the end of March, front monthWTI briefly traded as low as ~$55/bbl, before bouncing as high as ~$65/bbl and eventually finishing April at ~$58.20/bbl. 
  • Although tariff dynamics seem to be generally moderating from initially extreme levels, it is important to remember that oil markets are not just faced with tariff-related demand risks.  OPEC+ has announced meaningful supply additions into an already-skewed-toward-oversupply market.  Inventories will absorb some of OPEC+’s extra barrels, but if the cartel keeps coming, prices will have to fall enough to incentivize/force lower production from existing players.
  • OPEC+ will meet again May 5th to discuss its path forward.  Tensions are high, as Kazakhstan continues to overproduce dramatically and the rumor mill indicates another “production acceleration” could be possible for June.  This would mean bringing on more than the targeted monthly ~140kbopd increment of production.  Ugly if it happens.   
  • Volume reductions from US sanctions on Iran would appear to be the only potential near-term relief to oversupplied oil markets.  This seems to hinge on the status of ongoing nuclear talks between the two countries.  Foreign policy bingo, anyone? 
  • We continue to feel the risk/reward in oil markets is skewed to the downside and expect WTI to spend more time in the $50’s than the $60’s through the remainder of the year.  This is certainly one prognostication where we’d be happy to be wrong!
  • Natural gas was not immune to April’s volatility.  Front month NYMEX gas was over $4/mmbtu at the beginning of the month, spent some time briefly under $3/mmbtu and closed at ~$3.35/mmbtu (-19% m/m) as 1) the market started to worry that a trade war with China could impact LNG volumes and 2) gas storage levels loosened vs. historical averages.  Longer term gas was less impacted with NYMEX Calendar 2026 and 2027 dropping -4.9%(~$4.20/mmbtu) and -1.3% (~$3.85/mmbtu), respectively. 

INDUSTRY DYNAMICS

  • Lower commodity prices, potential tariff impacts and falling stock prices have energy industry executives both dismayed and incrementally cautious.  Private upstream operatorsappear to be reacting most quickly to the $10+/bbl drop in oil prices, with a few indicating they will release drilling rigs after current wells are completed and defer completions (DUC).  Public companies are mostly taking a wait-and-see approach to capital spending plans, although Matador Resources announced it would drop a rig in the Permian in June and reallocate capital to share repurchase.
  • We are strong advocates of share repurchase for energy companies with already-strong balance sheets and stocks trading at substantial discounts to NAV (with NAV determined at $60/bbl and gas at $3/mcf).  This will make increasing sense as/when/if oil prices trade in the $50’s (and stocks trade at/below current prices).  Hats off to Permian producer Diamondback Energy, pre-announcing Q1 operating metrics so it could take advantage of share price weakness to buy back shares. 
  • The Big Three OFS companies (Schlumberger, Halliburton and Baker Hughes) kicked off Q1 earnings season with disappointing results.  Reflecting the uncertain environment for both tariffs and drilling activity, guidance was generally lowered.  Sellside analysts have begun the process of lowering forward estimates.  Typically, in an industry slowdown, the first earnings revisions are never cautious/deep enough.  The one-day reaction to HAL, BKR and SLB results were -5.6%, -6.4% and -1.2%, respectively.  We will be watching for the point in time when OFS stocks ignore bad news. 
  • For the past several years, readers of this commentary have seen a steady stream of discussion regarding monthly M&A announcements.  We expect a 6-12 month hiatus from sizeable deals while companies assess the macro and wait for bid-ask equilibrium to emerge.  At these levels, stock-for-stock combinations will likely be the deal structure of choice as sellers won’t want to “cash out” at low prices.

ENERGY EQUITIES

Not a lot to say.  For the year, on a total return basis (price + dividends), energy indices are now between +2.6% (Midstream) to -22.9% (Oilfield Service).  Many stocks are off 30%+.  As of the end of April 2025, the upstream ETF we watch (XOP), has bounced +8.6% from the low.  For comparison, the S&P’s move off the bottom is +11.8%.  Q1 earnings calls will provide an overall view of how the industry plans to navigate the forward environment.  That will be helpful information for investors.  Overall, energy stocks are inexpensive on both cash flow and asset value metrics, but susceptible to further weakness on an oil move into the $50’s.  We remain slow and steady acquirers and expect our bullishness to increase with either elapsed time or lower stock prices.

April 2025 - Commentary from Dan Pickering

Timeframe

Add to calendar

Location

No items found.

Connect

No items found.

Sponsored

PEP Library

Explore Our Latest Insights

Visit page
Visit Library post
A rough month. Energy was the worst subsector in an incredibly choppy market.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Matador Resources is cutting 2025 drilling plans and capital spending by $100 million amid lower oil prices, while keeping flexibility to adjust production and rig count based on market conditions.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Despite plunging oil prices and investor jitters, seasoned energy investors remain cautiously optimistic, seeing long-term value as Trump pushes for energy dominance and OPEC raises supply.
Visit page
Visit Library post
U.S. tech giants are driving a global shift in climate compliance, pressuring energy and manufacturing sectors to meet stricter European sustainability standards.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Join hosts Josh Lowrey and Dan Pickering on the Energy In Transition Podcast, the premier voice for all things related to the energy transition..
Visit page
Visit Library post
Despite Energy Secretary Chris Wright’s assurances of a Trump-era “green light” for U.S. oil production, the sharp decline in Liberty Energy and oilfield service stocks signals deeper trouble for the shale industry amid weak crude prices, trade tensions, and dwindling demand.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Bad things are happening, fear is high and sentiment is awful.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Texas oil jobs at risk as market reels from Trump tariffs
Visit page
Visit Library post
Eager to stay in Mr. Trump’s good graces, oil executives refrain from publicly criticizing the president. But privately, ‘Everyone’s afraid.’
Visit page
Visit Library post
Explore how the latest 2025 tariffs could drive up vehicle prices, disrupt global supply chains, and reshape the future of the U.S. automotive industry.
Visit page
Visit Library post
A guide to how energy companies are refining their investor messaging to capitalize on sustainability progress, strengthen trust, and drive long-term value creation.
Visit page
Visit Library post
An analysis urging the energy sector to maintain focus on sustainability and ESG principles despite political shifts, emphasizing the volatility of independent voters and global regulatory trends.
Visit page
Visit Library post
U.S. natural gas producers and investors are ramping up activity in Louisiana’s Haynesville shale basin as rising LNG export demand and new project approvals drive expectations of a supply boom.
Visit page
Visit Library post
What’s driving oil prices in 2025 — market shifts, forecasts, and what traders should watch.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Exploring the evolving realities of the global energy transition, highlighting the challenges of net-zero goals, rising energy demand, and the geopolitical implications of resource security.

Upcoming Events

June 4 - 6 | Colorado Springs, CO
Visit page
Sept. 29 - Oct. 1 | Austin, TX
Visit page
Ready to get started?
Contact our specialized teams at PEP for more information.