PEP Library
Commentaries

January 2022 - Monthly Commentary from Dan Pickering

Full Post
Thinking about stocks, the chickens came home to roost in January. Rising interest rates and tightening commentary from the Federal Reserve sparked a meaningful downdraft by the major stock indices.

Happy New Year (in every sense of the word)! In the midst of a very, very tough overall stock market environment, energy had a stellar absolute and relative January. The S&P500 fell -5.3% during January, while Diversified Energy gained +18.1% (S&P 1500 Energy, S15ENRS), with the following energy subsector performance – Upstream/E&P +11.2% (XOP), Midstream +10.1% (AMZ) and oilfield services +22.2% (OIH). WTI oil was strong at +17.2% (~$88.15/bb) and natural gas ripped +30.7% (~$4.90/mcf).

Why did oil markets jam higher in January? Multiple narratives are at work. On the demand side, Omicron’s intensity is fading. It’s hard to find a virus mention on CNBC as deaths are down, market volatility is up and Q4 earnings are in focus. Rampant inflation fears drove increased interest from the financial community in hard assets and inflation protection. On the physical side, OPEC++ has consistently underdelivered on the promise of incremental barrels. In December, OPEC++ added only +90kbbls/day of its +400kbbls/day targeted production increase. Russia and Nigeria are the two largest “misses”, but at least half a dozen OPEC++ participants were below allowables. This is creating an increasingly prevalent undercurrent to the market that “spare capacity” is running short, which subsequently allows oil market participants to remain bullish, even though global inventories will likely rise during 2022. Finally, the drumbeat of war between Russia/Ukraine has to be adding some supply risk premium to near-term crude prices.

Looking at long-dated oil prices as a gauge of sentiment, enthusiasm and/or conviction – calendar year 2025 WTI crude futures have moved from the high $50’s to the mid $60’s since December 2021. In January 2022, the gain was +10%, compared to the ~+17% move in both front month WTI and calendar 2022 WTI. Perhaps it is OPEC spare capacity fears, perhaps it is growing conviction in US shale capex discipline, but the market is starting to believe there is something structural about the tightness in crude markets.

Away from unforecastable geopolitical events, our eyes remain glued to US shale capital discipline. So far, so good. We’ll be watching Q4 earnings results and commentary very closely. Both Chevron and Exxon recently highlighted Permian production growth. Yes, the Permian will grow in 2022, but we expect overall US 2022 production growth to come in well below consensus expectations. Wrap it all together – we’re not changing our $65-$85/bbl price range for 2022, which ironically lands us somewhat more “bearish” than many in the market. My, how things have changed in the past year! For the record, we aren’t bearish, we’re simply not using triple digit oil prices as our base case expectation.

US natural gas – strong as horseradish, with help from weather, rising oil prices and continued strength in global LNG prices. At this writing, 2022 full year natural gas is $4.90/mcf and 2023 is almost $4/mcf. History over the past decade says take the “under” when gas prices are at this level, and we’re not inclined to argue with that mindset. We’ll watch the Haynesville rig count for potential volume responses.

As the calendar turned to 2022, the US energy industry continued to consolidate. Chesapeake Energy purchased private Appalachia producer Chief, oilfield compression companies Exterran Corp and Enerflex Ltd. merged, and Permian basin E&P Earthstone Energy (ESTE) bought recently restructured Sable Energy from its creditor owners. Even with high(er) commodity prices, scale matters.

Maybe, just maybe, the pendulum is swinging back to rationality and more realistic expectations regarding decarbonization and the energy transition. The quick transition to renewables in Europe contributed to their ongoing energy crisis and the need to source expensive emergency supplies of fossil fuels. Perhaps as a result, the European Union is considering classifying natural gas and nuclear as a “sustainable investment”, a process that has sparked fierce debate amongst member countries. Acknowledging the practicality of a long energy transition, BlackRock CEO Larry Fink stepped back somewhat from prior aggressive statements regarding divestments from hydrocarbons and oil and gas companies. Meanwhile, letters from BlackRock fund managers highlighted natural gas “will play an important role” in the net zero transition. We believe the reality of the next several decades is All-Of-The-Above, so tradeoffs like the ones discussed above will have to be made.

Thinking about stocks, the chickens came home to roost in January. Rising interest rates and tightening commentary from the Federal Reserve sparked a meaningful downdraft by the major stock indices. The S&P500 fell by -5.3% and the Nasdaq Composite dropped -9.0%. The ensuing Growth-To-Value rotation was fierce. With rising oil prices, an inflation angle and clear “Value” characteristics, traditional energy was a significant beneficiary. Energy subsectors rose +10-22% in January. Cleantech was not so lucky. The Ishares Global Clean Energy ETF (ICLN) fell -11.4%, following a -25% downdraft in 2021. We are getting intrigued to sift through this wreckage but feel no particular urgency to step into the breech. Conversely, we stick by our view that traditional energy stocks are cheap on an absolute and relative basis and have the potential to re-rate higher during the year. Despite impressive performance in 2021 and January 2022, the deck remains stacked in favor of the sector.

As always, we appreciate your interest and welcome your questions.

January 2022 - Monthly Commentary from Dan Pickering

Timeframe

Add to calendar

Location

No items found.

Connect

No items found.

Sponsored

PEP Library

Explore Our Latest Insights

Visit page
Visit Library post
Shell refutes a Wall Street Journal report of early merger talks with BP, but speculation underscores BP’s vulnerability and the industry-shaking scale of any tie-up.
Visit page
Visit Library post
AI arms race fuels gas-heavy continuation vehicle wave
Visit page
Visit Library post
Dan Pickering, Founder and CIO of Pickering Energy Partners, sees supply and demand concerns returning to the forefront of the oil market with the removal of geopolitical risk from the Israel-Iran ceasefire.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Crude oil prices, maybe surprisingly, dipped modestly on Monday after spiking at the end of last week, even as Iran and Israel continue firing
Visit page
Visit Library post
Energy Aspects’ Richard Bronze and Pickering Energy Partners’ Dan Pickering, join ‘The Exchange’ to discuss the Israel-Iran conflict and how it may impact the oil sector.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Dan Pickering, Founder & CIO from Pickering Energy Partners, joins CNBC’s Dan Murphy to talk oil prices, and he says OPEC will win the market share war.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Rebound Month. The market turned up hard and energy followed
Visit page
Visit Library post
What if our path to energy decarbonization and global energy dominance didn’t rely on more rules, more penalties, and more government overreach, but instead on competition, transparency, and financial reward?
Visit page
Visit Library post
The feud has chilled the relationship between their CEOs. It comes to a head when arbitration starts Monday.
Visit page
Visit Library post
OPEC is pumping, and shale producers are pulling up rigs. Our experts see plenty of opportunities in the sector’s upheaval.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Dan Pickering joins stateside with CNBC Asia
Visit page
Visit Library post
BP’s falling share price has sparked takeover interest from global rivals eyeing its undervalued assets, risking the end of its 116-year independence.
Visit page
Visit Library post
The talented individuals who make up Hart Energy’s 2025 Forty Under 40 honorees represent a diverse set of disciplines.
Visit page
Visit Library post
Why BEV market share—not sales volume—matters most for EU CO₂ targets amid stricter rules, stalled growth, and industry-wide compliance challenges.
Visit page
Visit Library post
A rough month. Energy was the worst subsector in an incredibly choppy market.

Upcoming Events

Sept. 29 - Oct. 1 | Austin, TX
Visit page
Ready to get started?
Contact our specialized teams at PEP for more information.